The bad reviews are hilarious. I don't know that Shapiro planned to expose the review community as rubes, but he certainly did it. They all read like “we didn't understand it because we watch too many TikTok videos”.
Read Rod Dreher’s review which made me keen to see the film but while this is an otherwise fine piece it unfortunately has several spoilers which I think could have been omitted so …not happy! 😩
I haven’t seen this film yet but I find it interesting that Shapiro used a Christian character to tell the story when it was Jews who were severely persecuted in Soviet Russia. Stalin’s The Doctors’s plot so many Soviet Jews were murdered and sent to the gulag. Conditions for Russian Jews were so bad that we marched for them in the 70s to be allowed to emigrate. Nathan Sharansky being the most famous of Soviet Jewry. Many of my classmates in Jewish Day school were from Odessa. I guess he didn’t want alienate his audience.
It a little strange that the inquisitor here would quote Bakunin . That’s not someone who was held in high esteem in Stalinist Russia.I think an NKVD officer who favorably quoted Bakunin would have been in serious trouble. Probably of a lethal nature.
They aren't capturing the spirit of Dostoevsky, his ability to write multiple voices, his depiction of nihilism and insanity. In Darkness at Noon, Koestler does suggest, quite gently, that Christianity is morally superior to Communism, but Koestler did not have conventional religious beliefs. If anything, I think Koestler is arguing against certainty, in favor of doubt.
'Fjord' won the Palm D'Or this year. If people want a sympathetic depiction of Christianity they should watch that, although it's frankly not as good as the director's previous films. By comparison, this movie is mawkish propaganda.
The bad reviews are hilarious. I don't know that Shapiro planned to expose the review community as rubes, but he certainly did it. They all read like “we didn't understand it because we watch too many TikTok videos”.
A masterpiece about a masterpiece. Congratulations and thank you.
Wonderful review. Take care.
Read Rod Dreher’s review which made me keen to see the film but while this is an otherwise fine piece it unfortunately has several spoilers which I think could have been omitted so …not happy! 😩
I haven’t seen this film yet but I find it interesting that Shapiro used a Christian character to tell the story when it was Jews who were severely persecuted in Soviet Russia. Stalin’s The Doctors’s plot so many Soviet Jews were murdered and sent to the gulag. Conditions for Russian Jews were so bad that we marched for them in the 70s to be allowed to emigrate. Nathan Sharansky being the most famous of Soviet Jewry. Many of my classmates in Jewish Day school were from Odessa. I guess he didn’t want alienate his audience.
It a little strange that the inquisitor here would quote Bakunin . That’s not someone who was held in high esteem in Stalinist Russia.I think an NKVD officer who favorably quoted Bakunin would have been in serious trouble. Probably of a lethal nature.
Powerful review
They aren't capturing the spirit of Dostoevsky, his ability to write multiple voices, his depiction of nihilism and insanity. In Darkness at Noon, Koestler does suggest, quite gently, that Christianity is morally superior to Communism, but Koestler did not have conventional religious beliefs. If anything, I think Koestler is arguing against certainty, in favor of doubt.
'Fjord' won the Palm D'Or this year. If people want a sympathetic depiction of Christianity they should watch that, although it's frankly not as good as the director's previous films. By comparison, this movie is mawkish propaganda.
Have you read Invisible Ink by Brian McDonald? I think you might like it.