For the love of baby Jesus, can writers please stop putting their entire book in the present tense? Most godawful trend (among many godawful trends) in modern novels.
They think it conveys immediacy, making the reader feel there with the characters experiencing everything as it happens. But it’s just stilted and confusing. There are times in Normal People where she accidentally stumbles into past tense - “Two weeks ago they saw each other at a party…”. Present tense in novels always reminds me of Yogi Berra’s response when someone asked him for the time: “You mean now?”
I am on a creative writing course at the moment. The tutor, who is lovely, is a script writer and showed us a clip (garage scene) from No Country for Old Men. It was good as a film scene but would fall flat as a pancake in a novel without the descriptive writing we were told we didn't need. I fear we will not get on very well.
Great post. We need more voices willing to call out Sally Rooney’s hypocrisy, her writing, and her support for terrorism. What makes writers like Rooney especially disturbing is how much influence they have among women while promoting deeply anti-feminist ideas under the guise of feminism.
Rooney writes about privileged white people sitting around discussing capitalism, class, and how miserable they are, comfortably removed from poverty, war, and actual struggles for survival. Yet somehow she’s celebrated as one of the great intellectual and progressive voices of our generation.
The concepts in her writing remind me of Story of O and Emmanuelle, particularly how female submission and degradation gradually become normalized. Rooney makes these themes fashionable for a modern female audience. The cigarettes, the coffee, the intellectual conversations, the self-hatred. She makes emotional dysfunction and female submission seem sophisticated, cool, and profound.
And somehow, this gets celebrated as feminist literature. There’s something deeply disturbing about making female submission and degradation so familiar, even fashionable, that women may come to romanticize their own subjugation simply because they “chose” it.
I think The Story of O might be better written but it's a long time since I read it in guilty snatches in a second hand bookshop. The passages from Rooney don't encourage me to read her. She sounds like Margaret Drabble crossed with a Presbyterian nanny, without the sense of time and place. The cigarettes and coffee make me think I am in the 50s but I take it the setting is now. Doesn't work.
I agree that The Story of O is better written, and there’s much more to learn from its language and prose than from Rooney’s. What disturbs me less about people’s reaction to The Story of O is that progressive circles and society at large don’t hold up Anne Desclos’s work as an example of feminist writing or some important literary work of trauma and abuse. It depicts the extreme humiliation of a woman for the purpose of titillating men. Desclos even wrote it after her lover challenged her to write erotica like the Marquis de Sade, whose life and work are notorious for brutal sexual violence and cruelty toward women. A woman trying to impress a man by writing about the degradation of another woman.
Yet Rooney writes about what I see as very similar concepts, just with worse prose, and is celebrated as a progressive feminist voice. Her women find purpose through men, their approval, and their abuse. Beyond that, there is depression, meaninglessness, and acceptance of their own annihilation. The writing makes that surrender romantic and sexually compelling, and this is what women are being sold as feminism and a feminist author. And this is the same author who publicly supports Palestine Action, whose co-founder described Hamas’s October 7 attack as “resistance” and called for it to become a worldwide “tsunami.” How does celebrating her as a feminist sit alongside her support for an organization whose co-founder glorified an attack involving the rape, abduction, and mass murder of Jewish and Israeli civilians? Women’s humiliation and self-destruction become sophisticated, progressive, even aspirational. Modern feminists really need to ask themselves: why is women’s humiliation recognized as such in one book, but treated as something sophisticated and feminist in another?
I’d rather read https://www.sevenstories.com/books/4213-a-girl-s-story and I read Story of O as a college student as a banned book in Miami in 1960. I found it fascinating and horrifying for any woman to submit herself to being treated that way. But I had my own brush with S&M back then only she was a Tiger tamer from Romania 🥰
She is making abuse romantic. She fully belongs to that mindset that can say a man who beats his wife must love her a lot, a 50s Hollywood trope. Harmful, because it makes abuse of a woman a part of supposedly loving sex, when it's the opposite.
Which 1950’s Hollywood movies show that a man beating his wife must love her a lot? I am a big old Hollywood fan and haven’t run into this- I would be interested to learn more and see what I may have missed.
Well she has committed a criminal act and says she won't come to the UK because she fears being arrested. As things stand she has been giving financial support to an organisation officially deemed a terrorist organisation by there UK Govt.
How, at face value, is that "not concerning"?
So if I win the lottery and start financing The Taliban (if my political beliefs led me there) would that also not be of concern?
To be clear, the proscribed organisation are not (as far as I know) peopled by murderous thugs who bomb and kill.
If *I* was running the GOVT I don't think I would be as quick to call them terrorists...
but I don't actually KNOW everything this organisation does... a bit like Sinn Fein never shot people or blew things up (apparently)... but their mates in the IRA did
And PS I believe in a united Ireland...
So, point is, fight the fact that the organisation is proscribed, but until that designation is lifted, giving them money is a crime for which you can go to prison.
What Sally Rooney or any other writer or person does with their own money is their own business, as are their opinions. It’s key to that whole ‘freedom of speech’ thing wannabe influencers are so keen to defend. Until someone says something they disagree with, obviously.
You should decide if you’re a true literature essayist or just another foot soldier in the ongoing ad hominem wars against those who criticise the dominant authoritarian narrative.
Also, your posts need a strong editorial hand. They could easily get where they’re going in half the time.
She made it clear that her critique was about Rooney's writing and she did not engage in ad hominems. She never advocated for censorship of Rooney, she merely noted Rooney's hypocrisy. As for the "dominant authoritarian narrative", which side its coming from is what the fighting's all about, isn't it.
If her criticism was entirely about Rooney’s writing style then why did she spent the bulk of the first third of her article framing her distaste for Rooney’s views on Palestine or Israel? Neither have any bearing on writing style or voice.
Re: “dominant authoritarian narrative” Yes, I did say that because it’s true. We have one side demanding cancellation on the basis of a writer’s conservative views, and the conservative response is to demean via ad hominem attacks and the utilisation of establishment media to attack liberal writers amid hilarious suggestions of conservative victimisation.
None of it has anything to do with the fabric of literature. This lauding of books such as Karamazov is all well and good but it’s survivorship bias. We have no way of understanding what the prevailing narrative of the times were. But I am certain there were thousands of terrible books which have faded and commenters longing for the time of Homer.
Censorship and cancellation appears to be headed at those who don't join the Palestinians cause and who believe in biological reality, not towards people like Rooney. I object to censoring and cancelling anyone but notice it is the fellow travellers of women like Rooney who are doing the cancelling.
IT is 10% to be accurate. This format is a well-recognized style of writing, where what is in the news and recently acclaimed is summarized in order to lead into what the author actually wants to talk about. But I bet your question was rhetorical. Too bad it has an actual answer.
I do agree that she likes to waste so much time explaining why she dislikes others' art - be it for stylistic elements, theme, what have you. Maybe she could write about something that is well-written for a change?
You mentioned Hamas and trans rights. No one else did. It's the latest variant of Godwin’s Law: any discussion online will, sooner be hijacked by a mention of Hamas or trans rights. Well done, you are that contributor
Palestinian Action support what Hamas do, so it's legitimate to mention them. I'd bet a lot that Palestinian Action also support trans ideology, because those who are pro-palestinian tend to be pro-trans. That the two causes are mutually exclusive passes by those who want to be in all the right-on causes.
It’s funny to me that Hamas is anti-feminist when it is Israel who has conducted a genocide that has killed thousands of mothers, little girls, female journalists and the like. Doesn’t really get more anti-woman than that in my book. But I guess that’s just me.
Well, yes... but some people think that particular organisation shouldn't be proscribed. But YES, if the organisation is or has been clearly found to be blowing shit up (or worse) then openly stating you are FUNDING THEM is frankly bonkers,
Let me throw a hypothetical at you. Say, just say, that a lump of money from SR's UK sales, directly and specifically allows "a proscribed organisation" to set off a bomb which kills half a dozen innocent children... what then?
PS I am strongly PRO-Palestinian and I think that what is happening to the Palestinians is genocide assisted by the US and UK,
Hamas took lots of videos of October 7th if you’d care to watch the rapes and massacre so you can easily see it with your own eyes if you want the facts
I have never denied that Hamas did some awful stuff. I don’t condone ANY violence and have said that a few times in this thread. Seeing a video, seeing ten videos, seeing a hundred videos is not forensic analysis of the facts. But the Israeli government will have released their figures and the response to you killed (say) 3,000 of our people..
PAUSE JERUSALEM, Nov 10 (Reuters) - A spokesperson for Israel's foreign ministry said on Friday that the death toll from the Oct. 7 Hamas attack in southern Israel had been revised to around 1,200 from a previous government estimate of 1,400.
"Around 1,200 is the official number of victims of the October 7 massacre," spokesperson Lior Haiat said in a written statement.
So 1,200 deaths, every one wrong, every one obscene (but see later)
As for rapes, gangs rapes and sexual mutilation, it is pretty much standard practice in conflict to exaggerate the numbers. Serious unbiased investigations seem to indicate that the numbers are inflated.
In June 2024, The Times published a detailed investigative report concluding that Israel's claims about the scale and the formally sanctioned, systematic nature of sexual assaults did not stand up to scrutiny
As of January 2025, the former head of the security cases division in Israel's Southern District prosecutor's office said that no case was being filed due to a lack of evidence and complainants, which she said could be due to victims being dead or unwilling to come forward.
Don’t you find it remarkable that not one single charge has been brought? Not one?
IDF Genocide
Published in The BMJ (British Medical Journal)February 2026
Israel accepts Gaza death toll of 70 000, but experts say true number is much higher.
For one, how many deaths due to bombing in 2026?
One killing, one rape (by Hams fighters) is too many, YES, but the response by the IDF is nothing short of Genocide.
The Watson School of International Affairs (Brown University) write (of the first two years (less four days)
Since October 7, 2023, over ten percent of the population of Gaza has been directly killed or injured in two years of Israel’s war in Gaza. In addition, writes political scientist Neta Crawford (Co-Founder, Costs of War and Professor, University of Oxford), “the destruction of infrastructure – including energy, water, sanitation, agriculture, housing, and healthcare – [has] rendered the conditions of life so difficult as to cause long term harm for the rest of the population.”
As of October 3, 2025, according to the Gaza Ministry of Health, 67,075 people have been killed and 169,430 people have been injured, totaling 236,505 casualties, out of the approximately 2.2 million people living in Gaza before the war.
Recent analysis by public health experts suggests that the number of fatalities reported by the Gaza Ministry of Health, which faces many obstacles to making a full account of the deaths, may be a significant undercount of the violent deaths.
In the two years since the October 7, 2023 Hamas attack on Israel, the U.S. government has spent 21.7 BILLION dollars in military aid to Israel and 9.65-12.07 BILLION on related operations in the wider Middle East, for a total of over $31 billion and counting
I never once mentioned Hamas or October 7th. I answered purely about this essayist’s hypocrisy in attacking Rooney. Please stop attributing viewpoints to me that I have never once even hinted at.
I can't comment on the actualities of October 7th or who or what celebrated. I didn't see with my own eyes and/but I know the news is extremely biased. Remember "Iraquis killing babies in incubators"?
What is unequivocal is just how extreme the response has been. The only honest word for it is GENOCIDE.
I am pro-Palestian because they are underdogs and the IDF is pumped full of Trump-US money and has been systematically murdering Palstinians effectively "every day" for many, many years.
She lost me at “taste of her own medicine” whatever that means, then I skimmed the rest to find where there was an actual discussion or evidence about what she didn’t like. Seems to be that it’s too similar to 50 Shades of Grey, and that there was a lack of imagery.
"What Sally Rooney or any other writer or person does with their own money is their own business, "
UNLESS what she does is officially a crime.
"as are their opinions."
She has my support to think whatever she chooses
" It’s key to that whole ‘freedom of speech’ thing wannabe influencers are so keen to defend. Until someone says something they disagree with, obviously."
The UK Government did not pressure Rooney or her publisher. Rooney created the pressure by openly stating she was giving money to a proscribed organisation. Her publisher stated since they cannot pay her royalties in the UK (for UK sales) they felt they couldn't keep selling her books in the UK.
Nowhere does Rooney say (or her publisher say) that she has been "silenced"
This is NOT about Free Speech. If you read what she says, what her publisher says, this is 100% clear. Certain people are framing this as censorship when it isn't.
To rephrase the argument. Say The Troubles were still ongoing, and an author publicly announced she (or he) was giving all their profit to the IRA.
You would get that this was a criminal act, right?
On the 5th of November the Supreme Court will, in all probability, de-proscribe PA, rendering that last straw of criminality Sally Rooney’s critics cling onto as moot.
The issue I have with this article is this writer's ad hominem attack on Ms Rooney and her view that she is a “terrible writer”, who started her article outlining why she disagreed with her before tacking on her subjective views on Rooney’s skills as a writer. Which is it? Is Sally Rooney genuinely a terrible writer or is she simply being insulted and having her talents demeaned as transparently as the fable of the Fox and the Grapes?
I feel I'm being pushed into a corner here by the mores of social media to defend Sally Rooney to the death but I'm not a huge fan myself. I liked but didn't love Nornal People. Other books of hers have left me indifferent. However, even if she's not for me, I can at least recognize her considerable talent without recourse to insult.
Are we supposed to take this seriously as literary criticism or is literature being used as a convenient cloak for an excuse to rant against those who take a stand against the prevailing media norm?
Plus, if you think finding an IRA-supporting writer at the time of The Troubles would be difficult I suggest you start with Brendan Behan and go from there. Indeed, elected members of the Westminster parliament donated tithes of their salaries to the IRA.
Alex, a person can believe in a United Ireland (as I do) but still believe murder by gun or bomb is wrong.
I believe in the Palestinian cause but I can't condone October 7th
I believe the actions of the IDF is barely-masked genocide but I do not hate Jews.
IF a person, say, supported the IRA, he or she should open the sentence into a paragraph. Example (NOT my thoughts) "I support the IRA's aims and I support them blowing people up, shooting people, making people disappear, knee-capping and every other kind of violence."
I seriously loathe Trump-America and I would REJOICE to find he died in his sleep, but I would NOT condone violence against him
I think I have already said that supporting terrorism with your own money is illegal. If Rooney gives money to Palestine Action she is committing a crime. This is why she has pulled her books in the UK.
I'm not a huge fan of Sally Rooney either, I find her boring and middlebrow. But I must admit I'm a little frustrated by the political info we're sharing here.
The liberal establishment acts like a bunch of hypocritical, privileged liars. They demonize people just for having the courage to disagree. They've basically held the keys to culture, discouraging anyone from thinking for themselves and promoting lots of condescending garbage.
But Is what happened to Sally Rooney fair? I doubt it.
I don't think Palestine Action is clearly a terrorist group. They were labeled terrorists because they try to disrupt weapons manufacturing. They sprayed red paint on a military surveillance aircraft. They damaged a factory that produces weapons. The "terrorist" label is controversial in the UK, carried out by a PM who had financial and personal connections to the Israeli Labor Party, and was backed by Donald Trump because of course it was.
Are their actions radical? Yes. I'm Jewish myself, and I'm not saying I endorse them. In their 40 actions, they did once badly hurt a person, unplanned, while carrying out an action (Kate Evans in 2024). I don't endorse that. But I think there's a difference between property damage--specifically, damaging weapons so they can't go on to kill thousands--and intending to hurt innocent people. Terrorists intend to hurt innocent people. Palestine Action is clearly anti-war, not pro-hurting Jewish people.
Meanwhile, American billionaires are donating hundreds millions of dollars to Trump's crypto account to get him and his cronies elected. They're not trying to stop a war, they're trying to consolidate even more money and power. Who's confiscating their earnings? They're making political donations too. They're buying our democracy from us before our very eyes. And they're getting away with it.
Not that you asked, but yeah, the situation in Palestine and Israel is really tough. Israeli citizens are justifiably enraged about October 7th and terrified of what could happen to them in the Middle East. But what their government is doing to Palestinian citizens is wrong. Both things can be true. That's why everybody argues about it and nobody can seem to figure it out.
I think your frustration toward the liberal establishment is justified. You say it yourself, we need a moral standard that is deeply true. Minorities experience unique and elevated harms. Literature doesn't have to be queer, Marxist, or perfectly unproblematic to be great. Both of these things are true. I hope you see this, Liza.
Thank you for responding and sharing how you feel. I agree, what Hamas has done to innocent citizens, Israelis and their own, is wrong. I doubt they're above sacrificing their own people.
But this is also true. 90% of Gazans (1.98 million people) and counting no longer have homes and are living in refugee camps. If we continue bombing them because of Hamas and making them live in refugee camps, they will die.
I say "we" as a Jew and an American. If we continue dropping bombs, we may eventually force Palestine to surrender, but the conflict will reignite in the future because it has not been solved. The only ways to end the conflict are to come to a peaceful agreement or to kill all the Palestinians. Thousands if not millions more Palestinians will die, and Israelis will die too.
A peaceful agreement seems nearly impossible, and you probably have a lot of reasons for why that is. But the other option is simply unacceptable. I do not alone have an answer for how to fix this. Maybe if we were all talking about that, we could figure it out together.
When you look at it from this perspective, this discussion of Rooney deserving a "taste of her own medicine" for funding "radical Marxist groups" feels beside the point. There was a (controversial) group trying to stop bombs from being dropped on Palestinians, Rooney financially supported it, and now we're treating it as fodder for the culture war. We're all so angry, pointing fingers at each other, red sports team vs blue sports team, conservatives vs liberals, Israel vs Palestinine, and whoever happens to be more powerful at the moment gets their 5 minutes of revenge. Big whoop. This is what generates the attention and comments, while the lives and society of millions of Palestinians, and our own American democracy, gradually slip away.
You have no idea the amount of hate and entitlement those Palestinians have, I say that as Iranian woman born and raised there and a Muslim. The wealth of my country has been spent on nothing but killing Jews. You living in the USA can’t image what goes on in the Middle East.
The UK judiciary are undecided about that, several judges now finding against the government, it's going to appeal. So this is not as slam-dunk settled as you seem to think. Criminal damage can be prosecuted but there is often a valid reasonable defence. Trivial example: in a fire one can break down a door to save a life. Can one spray paint weapons to stop them being used against civilians? I think so.
What's to be understood about a group which struck a woman in the back with a sledgehammer and goes about in the night daubing Jewish-owned businesses with red paint meant to look like blood?
One person atryck the police officer. I condemn that. But to condemn the group for the actions of one person would have every group condemned. One rogue IDF soldier would condemn Israel. But there are many thousands of war criminals in the IDF! Let's hear you speak out against that.
I like how you immediately jump to the conclusion that anyone who thinks there are good reasons to proscribe Palestine Action couldn't possibly think Israel has committed war crimes.
Not everything is a game of "arguments as soldiers".
And if you think Samuel Corner is the sole bad apple in Palestine Action and the rest of them are angels who wouldn't hurt a fly, you are sorely mistaken. Corner broke the police officer's spine in the middle of a terrorist action in which he and has compatriots caused £1.2 million in property damage.
And, obviously, you don't even consider daubing red paint on Jewish-owned businesses in the UK worthy of condemnation. I wonder why.
There are few angels. But a good cause is a good cause despite its proponents. I'm not going to condemn arithmeticians simply because Hitler also believed 2+2=4. Similarly Zionism is a bad idea even though Hitler was a supporter of it 🙂. Don't condemn the idea because you don't like some of those who express it because then no idea is good.
However, silence is too often too telling. Silence is too often nothing but cowardly complicity.
Calling a writer 'terrible' because their work doesn't conform to 19th-century standards of interiority or scope sets a rather impossible bar.
If we judge every artistic era by whether it mimics the grand, operatic architecture of Victorian realism, we miss how different registers function. Modern minimalism uses flat prose and suppressed subtext intentionally—not out of incompetence, but as a diagnostic tool for a different kind of human experience. Conflating personal distaste for a register with 'bad writing' just closes the door on actual criticism.
Flat prose is boring to read and if you can't get at the subtext as a reader then there is little point in the book. I read for plessure, not to have a world view shoved at me in a limited vocabulary.
I see what you mean, but I think the subtext in flat prose is actually found in what isn't being said.
When an author strips away all the decorative adjectives, speech marks, and internal monologues, they force you to read between the lines of the dialogue. The restraint is the point—the emotion isn't handed to you on a silver platter; it's buried in the cold, clinical distance between the characters.
It’s definitely a polarising style, but when it works, the 'boredom' is actually tension.
Jack Kerouac’s American haikus are not traditional Japanese haikus because they abandon the rigid 5-7-5 syllable structure, yet they are intentionally crafted as an adapted Western form.
I love Japanese haikus, but I'm no purist. Do you like Japanese haikus?
Out of curiosity, are you familiar with Kerouac's Mexico City Blues?
I ask because it's the exact polar opposite of Rooney's flat minimalism. It's written like a chaotic jazz jam session with a massive, spontaneous vocabulary, but it poses the same problem from the other direction—the subtext is so buried in the linguistic noise that you have to fight just to find a coherent worldview.
If Rooney is too empty for you, I’m curious if you think Kerouac is too loud, or if that’s closer to what you mean by reading for pleasure.
I have not read NORMAL PEOPLE and don't feel drawn to it, but I found INTERMEZZO to be an interesting and stylistically varied portrait of a particular social milieu whose characters grew and gained insight into themselves. So the broadbrush generalizations of Rooney's writing that you extrapolate from this some years old book, even if, for the sake of argument, you are right about it, are unpersuasive. As for her deserving a taste of her own medicine, two wrongs don't make a right. I dislike cultural boycotts and governmental policies that restrict expressive activity even more.
I agree with your comments on Intermezzo. I was really drawn into the lives of the two brothers and found their relationship portrayed a considerable depth of emotion.
Thank you for saving me the trouble of reading these two awful books. Not that I had the slightest intention of reading either of them, but the juxtaposition of the two BDSM passages is marvelously revealing.
What is going on? When I was growing up, the world was still pretty small for most people. We turned to books to broaden our experience. Thanks to the Web and the hundred-channel universe, the world is now much too big for most people. They feel lost in it. As a result, they seem to desperately crave affirmation of their particular place in it.
You can see this everywhere. Christian literature, for instance, whatever it pretends, is not evangelizing, either in purpose or effect. It is affirming its readers in their existing faith and in their righteousness. The Marxist-feminist literature similarly exists to affirm primarily young women in their prejudices and fears. They have been taught that trust and dependency are dangerous and will lead to a loss of self, which leaves not much but a howling wasteland of fear and desire in their relationships with men. They seek affirmation that this miserable existence they have claimed for themselves is normal and justified, and the Sally Rooneys of the world supply that affirmation.
But reading for affirmation is a very different thing from reading for experience. Experience is rich and detailed and particular and open-ended. It opens gates; it doesn't build fences. Reading for affirmation, on the other hand, sticks to familiar ground. Rich detail is superfluous. Particularity of experience is beside the point, because it is the assurance of absolute sameness and familiarity that is wanted. It exists only to say, yes, the world is just what you think it is, and it's not your fault, but someone else's.
And this is why I keep insisting that great literature is not about great ideas. That is just another form of affirmative literature. It differs only in what it is affirming. It appeals only to those who want that particular idea affirmed.
Sally Rooney, then, is writing just as she should for the kind of book she is writing, for the kind of audience she is writing it for. Literary style should fit the kind of book you are writing and the kind of audience you are writing it for. Sally Rooney is clearly good at what she does. The problem is that she affirms that which should not be affirmed at all.
The antidote to this is not to produce a work that affirms the opposite. It is to produce works that provide particular authentic human experience through specific stories of unforgettable characters. Experience is the acid that destroys bad ideas. That is the kind of book that stands a chance of curing a reader of their desire to be affirmed in Sally Rooney world.
I know nothing about this writer. But that her political interests come up right away in judgments of the aesthetic merit of her writing is the butcher's thumb on the scale.
For the love of baby Jesus, can writers please stop putting their entire book in the present tense? Most godawful trend (among many godawful trends) in modern novels.
They think it conveys immediacy, making the reader feel there with the characters experiencing everything as it happens. But it’s just stilted and confusing. There are times in Normal People where she accidentally stumbles into past tense - “Two weeks ago they saw each other at a party…”. Present tense in novels always reminds me of Yogi Berra’s response when someone asked him for the time: “You mean now?”
Présent tense can be effective. What is your problem with it? It’s not a trend. It’s a craft choice.
Only Damon Runyon was able to pull that feat off. Elsewhere I heartily concur. Stories are told in the past tense.
Hilary Mantell did it quite well. Still distancing, however.
Mediocrity is virtue. It's the dream of bureaucrats and middle school media coordinators.
Also of creative writing tutors.
Yes James.
I wrote an article way back... Dear God, just checked it was 2006
https://www.writerswrite.com/journal/the-disease-of-competence-4061
I am on a creative writing course at the moment. The tutor, who is lovely, is a script writer and showed us a clip (garage scene) from No Country for Old Men. It was good as a film scene but would fall flat as a pancake in a novel without the descriptive writing we were told we didn't need. I fear we will not get on very well.
Great post. We need more voices willing to call out Sally Rooney’s hypocrisy, her writing, and her support for terrorism. What makes writers like Rooney especially disturbing is how much influence they have among women while promoting deeply anti-feminist ideas under the guise of feminism.
Rooney writes about privileged white people sitting around discussing capitalism, class, and how miserable they are, comfortably removed from poverty, war, and actual struggles for survival. Yet somehow she’s celebrated as one of the great intellectual and progressive voices of our generation.
The concepts in her writing remind me of Story of O and Emmanuelle, particularly how female submission and degradation gradually become normalized. Rooney makes these themes fashionable for a modern female audience. The cigarettes, the coffee, the intellectual conversations, the self-hatred. She makes emotional dysfunction and female submission seem sophisticated, cool, and profound.
And somehow, this gets celebrated as feminist literature. There’s something deeply disturbing about making female submission and degradation so familiar, even fashionable, that women may come to romanticize their own subjugation simply because they “chose” it.
I think The Story of O might be better written but it's a long time since I read it in guilty snatches in a second hand bookshop. The passages from Rooney don't encourage me to read her. She sounds like Margaret Drabble crossed with a Presbyterian nanny, without the sense of time and place. The cigarettes and coffee make me think I am in the 50s but I take it the setting is now. Doesn't work.
I agree that The Story of O is better written, and there’s much more to learn from its language and prose than from Rooney’s. What disturbs me less about people’s reaction to The Story of O is that progressive circles and society at large don’t hold up Anne Desclos’s work as an example of feminist writing or some important literary work of trauma and abuse. It depicts the extreme humiliation of a woman for the purpose of titillating men. Desclos even wrote it after her lover challenged her to write erotica like the Marquis de Sade, whose life and work are notorious for brutal sexual violence and cruelty toward women. A woman trying to impress a man by writing about the degradation of another woman.
Yet Rooney writes about what I see as very similar concepts, just with worse prose, and is celebrated as a progressive feminist voice. Her women find purpose through men, their approval, and their abuse. Beyond that, there is depression, meaninglessness, and acceptance of their own annihilation. The writing makes that surrender romantic and sexually compelling, and this is what women are being sold as feminism and a feminist author. And this is the same author who publicly supports Palestine Action, whose co-founder described Hamas’s October 7 attack as “resistance” and called for it to become a worldwide “tsunami.” How does celebrating her as a feminist sit alongside her support for an organization whose co-founder glorified an attack involving the rape, abduction, and mass murder of Jewish and Israeli civilians? Women’s humiliation and self-destruction become sophisticated, progressive, even aspirational. Modern feminists really need to ask themselves: why is women’s humiliation recognized as such in one book, but treated as something sophisticated and feminist in another?
I’d rather read https://www.sevenstories.com/books/4213-a-girl-s-story and I read Story of O as a college student as a banned book in Miami in 1960. I found it fascinating and horrifying for any woman to submit herself to being treated that way. But I had my own brush with S&M back then only she was a Tiger tamer from Romania 🥰
Well said!
why don't you call of Epstein file predators if you are so concerned. I don't think sally rooney has done anything concerning.
She is making abuse romantic. She fully belongs to that mindset that can say a man who beats his wife must love her a lot, a 50s Hollywood trope. Harmful, because it makes abuse of a woman a part of supposedly loving sex, when it's the opposite.
Which 1950’s Hollywood movies show that a man beating his wife must love her a lot? I am a big old Hollywood fan and haven’t run into this- I would be interested to learn more and see what I may have missed.
A Streetcar Named Desire
Well she has committed a criminal act and says she won't come to the UK because she fears being arrested. As things stand she has been giving financial support to an organisation officially deemed a terrorist organisation by there UK Govt.
How, at face value, is that "not concerning"?
So if I win the lottery and start financing The Taliban (if my political beliefs led me there) would that also not be of concern?
To be clear, the proscribed organisation are not (as far as I know) peopled by murderous thugs who bomb and kill.
If *I* was running the GOVT I don't think I would be as quick to call them terrorists...
but I don't actually KNOW everything this organisation does... a bit like Sinn Fein never shot people or blew things up (apparently)... but their mates in the IRA did
And PS I believe in a united Ireland...
So, point is, fight the fact that the organisation is proscribed, but until that designation is lifted, giving them money is a crime for which you can go to prison.
It's not rocket science.
I applaud this.
What Sally Rooney or any other writer or person does with their own money is their own business, as are their opinions. It’s key to that whole ‘freedom of speech’ thing wannabe influencers are so keen to defend. Until someone says something they disagree with, obviously.
You should decide if you’re a true literature essayist or just another foot soldier in the ongoing ad hominem wars against those who criticise the dominant authoritarian narrative.
Also, your posts need a strong editorial hand. They could easily get where they’re going in half the time.
She made it clear that her critique was about Rooney's writing and she did not engage in ad hominems. She never advocated for censorship of Rooney, she merely noted Rooney's hypocrisy. As for the "dominant authoritarian narrative", which side its coming from is what the fighting's all about, isn't it.
If her criticism was entirely about Rooney’s writing style then why did she spent the bulk of the first third of her article framing her distaste for Rooney’s views on Palestine or Israel? Neither have any bearing on writing style or voice.
Re: “dominant authoritarian narrative” Yes, I did say that because it’s true. We have one side demanding cancellation on the basis of a writer’s conservative views, and the conservative response is to demean via ad hominem attacks and the utilisation of establishment media to attack liberal writers amid hilarious suggestions of conservative victimisation.
None of it has anything to do with the fabric of literature. This lauding of books such as Karamazov is all well and good but it’s survivorship bias. We have no way of understanding what the prevailing narrative of the times were. But I am certain there were thousands of terrible books which have faded and commenters longing for the time of Homer.
Censorship and cancellation appears to be headed at those who don't join the Palestinians cause and who believe in biological reality, not towards people like Rooney. I object to censoring and cancelling anyone but notice it is the fellow travellers of women like Rooney who are doing the cancelling.
IT is 10% to be accurate. This format is a well-recognized style of writing, where what is in the news and recently acclaimed is summarized in order to lead into what the author actually wants to talk about. But I bet your question was rhetorical. Too bad it has an actual answer.
I do agree that she likes to waste so much time explaining why she dislikes others' art - be it for stylistic elements, theme, what have you. Maybe she could write about something that is well-written for a change?
The dominant narrative appears to be pro Hamas and pro trans. Neither particularly women friendly.
You mentioned Hamas and trans rights. No one else did. It's the latest variant of Godwin’s Law: any discussion online will, sooner be hijacked by a mention of Hamas or trans rights. Well done, you are that contributor
Palestinian Action support what Hamas do, so it's legitimate to mention them. I'd bet a lot that Palestinian Action also support trans ideology, because those who are pro-palestinian tend to be pro-trans. That the two causes are mutually exclusive passes by those who want to be in all the right-on causes.
It’s funny to me that Hamas is anti-feminist when it is Israel who has conducted a genocide that has killed thousands of mothers, little girls, female journalists and the like. Doesn’t really get more anti-woman than that in my book. But I guess that’s just me.
Israel has not committed genocide. Hamas definitely has using its people as human shields.
Funding terrorism is illegal.
“I ❤️ NY” and “Frankie Says Relax” are two other t-shirt slogans but you won't win any debates by quoting them either
Well, yes... but some people think that particular organisation shouldn't be proscribed. But YES, if the organisation is or has been clearly found to be blowing shit up (or worse) then openly stating you are FUNDING THEM is frankly bonkers,
Let me throw a hypothetical at you. Say, just say, that a lump of money from SR's UK sales, directly and specifically allows "a proscribed organisation" to set off a bomb which kills half a dozen innocent children... what then?
PS I am strongly PRO-Palestinian and I think that what is happening to the Palestinians is genocide assisted by the US and UK,
PPS I thought we were talking about shit writing
Alex
Hamas took lots of videos of October 7th if you’d care to watch the rapes and massacre so you can easily see it with your own eyes if you want the facts
I have never denied that Hamas did some awful stuff. I don’t condone ANY violence and have said that a few times in this thread. Seeing a video, seeing ten videos, seeing a hundred videos is not forensic analysis of the facts. But the Israeli government will have released their figures and the response to you killed (say) 3,000 of our people..
PAUSE JERUSALEM, Nov 10 (Reuters) - A spokesperson for Israel's foreign ministry said on Friday that the death toll from the Oct. 7 Hamas attack in southern Israel had been revised to around 1,200 from a previous government estimate of 1,400.
"Around 1,200 is the official number of victims of the October 7 massacre," spokesperson Lior Haiat said in a written statement.
So 1,200 deaths, every one wrong, every one obscene (but see later)
As for rapes, gangs rapes and sexual mutilation, it is pretty much standard practice in conflict to exaggerate the numbers. Serious unbiased investigations seem to indicate that the numbers are inflated.
In June 2024, The Times published a detailed investigative report concluding that Israel's claims about the scale and the formally sanctioned, systematic nature of sexual assaults did not stand up to scrutiny
As of January 2025, the former head of the security cases division in Israel's Southern District prosecutor's office said that no case was being filed due to a lack of evidence and complainants, which she said could be due to victims being dead or unwilling to come forward.
Don’t you find it remarkable that not one single charge has been brought? Not one?
IDF Genocide
Published in The BMJ (British Medical Journal)February 2026
Israel accepts Gaza death toll of 70 000, but experts say true number is much higher.
For one, how many deaths due to bombing in 2026?
One killing, one rape (by Hams fighters) is too many, YES, but the response by the IDF is nothing short of Genocide.
The Watson School of International Affairs (Brown University) write (of the first two years (less four days)
Since October 7, 2023, over ten percent of the population of Gaza has been directly killed or injured in two years of Israel’s war in Gaza. In addition, writes political scientist Neta Crawford (Co-Founder, Costs of War and Professor, University of Oxford), “the destruction of infrastructure – including energy, water, sanitation, agriculture, housing, and healthcare – [has] rendered the conditions of life so difficult as to cause long term harm for the rest of the population.”
As of October 3, 2025, according to the Gaza Ministry of Health, 67,075 people have been killed and 169,430 people have been injured, totaling 236,505 casualties, out of the approximately 2.2 million people living in Gaza before the war.
Recent analysis by public health experts suggests that the number of fatalities reported by the Gaza Ministry of Health, which faces many obstacles to making a full account of the deaths, may be a significant undercount of the violent deaths.
In the two years since the October 7, 2023 Hamas attack on Israel, the U.S. government has spent 21.7 BILLION dollars in military aid to Israel and 9.65-12.07 BILLION on related operations in the wider Middle East, for a total of over $31 billion and counting
I never once mentioned Hamas or October 7th. I answered purely about this essayist’s hypocrisy in attacking Rooney. Please stop attributing viewpoints to me that I have never once even hinted at.
I agree re funding terrorists. Not sure why you are pro-palestinian given that most of Gaza cheered on rspe, murder, child murder and kidnapping.
I can't comment on the actualities of October 7th or who or what celebrated. I didn't see with my own eyes and/but I know the news is extremely biased. Remember "Iraquis killing babies in incubators"?
What is unequivocal is just how extreme the response has been. The only honest word for it is GENOCIDE.
I am pro-Palestian because they are underdogs and the IDF is pumped full of Trump-US money and has been systematically murdering Palstinians effectively "every day" for many, many years.
You need to read some history mate
Hard agree.
She lost me at “taste of her own medicine” whatever that means, then I skimmed the rest to find where there was an actual discussion or evidence about what she didn’t like. Seems to be that it’s too similar to 50 Shades of Grey, and that there was a lack of imagery.
Like? Ok and…?
💀
The dominant authoritarian narrative… wut
"What Sally Rooney or any other writer or person does with their own money is their own business, "
UNLESS what she does is officially a crime.
"as are their opinions."
She has my support to think whatever she chooses
" It’s key to that whole ‘freedom of speech’ thing wannabe influencers are so keen to defend. Until someone says something they disagree with, obviously."
The UK Government did not pressure Rooney or her publisher. Rooney created the pressure by openly stating she was giving money to a proscribed organisation. Her publisher stated since they cannot pay her royalties in the UK (for UK sales) they felt they couldn't keep selling her books in the UK.
Nowhere does Rooney say (or her publisher say) that she has been "silenced"
This is NOT about Free Speech. If you read what she says, what her publisher says, this is 100% clear. Certain people are framing this as censorship when it isn't.
To rephrase the argument. Say The Troubles were still ongoing, and an author publicly announced she (or he) was giving all their profit to the IRA.
You would get that this was a criminal act, right?
On the 5th of November the Supreme Court will, in all probability, de-proscribe PA, rendering that last straw of criminality Sally Rooney’s critics cling onto as moot.
The issue I have with this article is this writer's ad hominem attack on Ms Rooney and her view that she is a “terrible writer”, who started her article outlining why she disagreed with her before tacking on her subjective views on Rooney’s skills as a writer. Which is it? Is Sally Rooney genuinely a terrible writer or is she simply being insulted and having her talents demeaned as transparently as the fable of the Fox and the Grapes?
I feel I'm being pushed into a corner here by the mores of social media to defend Sally Rooney to the death but I'm not a huge fan myself. I liked but didn't love Nornal People. Other books of hers have left me indifferent. However, even if she's not for me, I can at least recognize her considerable talent without recourse to insult.
Are we supposed to take this seriously as literary criticism or is literature being used as a convenient cloak for an excuse to rant against those who take a stand against the prevailing media norm?
Plus, if you think finding an IRA-supporting writer at the time of The Troubles would be difficult I suggest you start with Brendan Behan and go from there. Indeed, elected members of the Westminster parliament donated tithes of their salaries to the IRA.
Alex, a person can believe in a United Ireland (as I do) but still believe murder by gun or bomb is wrong.
I believe in the Palestinian cause but I can't condone October 7th
I believe the actions of the IDF is barely-masked genocide but I do not hate Jews.
IF a person, say, supported the IRA, he or she should open the sentence into a paragraph. Example (NOT my thoughts) "I support the IRA's aims and I support them blowing people up, shooting people, making people disappear, knee-capping and every other kind of violence."
I seriously loathe Trump-America and I would REJOICE to find he died in his sleep, but I would NOT condone violence against him
You're answering points that only you made. None of them made or mentioned by me
I think I have already said that supporting terrorism with your own money is illegal. If Rooney gives money to Palestine Action she is committing a crime. This is why she has pulled her books in the UK.
Amen
I'm not a huge fan of Sally Rooney either, I find her boring and middlebrow. But I must admit I'm a little frustrated by the political info we're sharing here.
The liberal establishment acts like a bunch of hypocritical, privileged liars. They demonize people just for having the courage to disagree. They've basically held the keys to culture, discouraging anyone from thinking for themselves and promoting lots of condescending garbage.
But Is what happened to Sally Rooney fair? I doubt it.
I don't think Palestine Action is clearly a terrorist group. They were labeled terrorists because they try to disrupt weapons manufacturing. They sprayed red paint on a military surveillance aircraft. They damaged a factory that produces weapons. The "terrorist" label is controversial in the UK, carried out by a PM who had financial and personal connections to the Israeli Labor Party, and was backed by Donald Trump because of course it was.
Are their actions radical? Yes. I'm Jewish myself, and I'm not saying I endorse them. In their 40 actions, they did once badly hurt a person, unplanned, while carrying out an action (Kate Evans in 2024). I don't endorse that. But I think there's a difference between property damage--specifically, damaging weapons so they can't go on to kill thousands--and intending to hurt innocent people. Terrorists intend to hurt innocent people. Palestine Action is clearly anti-war, not pro-hurting Jewish people.
Meanwhile, American billionaires are donating hundreds millions of dollars to Trump's crypto account to get him and his cronies elected. They're not trying to stop a war, they're trying to consolidate even more money and power. Who's confiscating their earnings? They're making political donations too. They're buying our democracy from us before our very eyes. And they're getting away with it.
Not that you asked, but yeah, the situation in Palestine and Israel is really tough. Israeli citizens are justifiably enraged about October 7th and terrified of what could happen to them in the Middle East. But what their government is doing to Palestinian citizens is wrong. Both things can be true. That's why everybody argues about it and nobody can seem to figure it out.
I think your frustration toward the liberal establishment is justified. You say it yourself, we need a moral standard that is deeply true. Minorities experience unique and elevated harms. Literature doesn't have to be queer, Marxist, or perfectly unproblematic to be great. Both of these things are true. I hope you see this, Liza.
What Hamas is doing to Gazans is wrong, using them as human shields and taking the aid meant for them and using it to fund terrorism.
Thank you for responding and sharing how you feel. I agree, what Hamas has done to innocent citizens, Israelis and their own, is wrong. I doubt they're above sacrificing their own people.
But this is also true. 90% of Gazans (1.98 million people) and counting no longer have homes and are living in refugee camps. If we continue bombing them because of Hamas and making them live in refugee camps, they will die.
I say "we" as a Jew and an American. If we continue dropping bombs, we may eventually force Palestine to surrender, but the conflict will reignite in the future because it has not been solved. The only ways to end the conflict are to come to a peaceful agreement or to kill all the Palestinians. Thousands if not millions more Palestinians will die, and Israelis will die too.
A peaceful agreement seems nearly impossible, and you probably have a lot of reasons for why that is. But the other option is simply unacceptable. I do not alone have an answer for how to fix this. Maybe if we were all talking about that, we could figure it out together.
When you look at it from this perspective, this discussion of Rooney deserving a "taste of her own medicine" for funding "radical Marxist groups" feels beside the point. There was a (controversial) group trying to stop bombs from being dropped on Palestinians, Rooney financially supported it, and now we're treating it as fodder for the culture war. We're all so angry, pointing fingers at each other, red sports team vs blue sports team, conservatives vs liberals, Israel vs Palestinine, and whoever happens to be more powerful at the moment gets their 5 minutes of revenge. Big whoop. This is what generates the attention and comments, while the lives and society of millions of Palestinians, and our own American democracy, gradually slip away.
You have no idea the amount of hate and entitlement those Palestinians have, I say that as Iranian woman born and raised there and a Muslim. The wealth of my country has been spent on nothing but killing Jews. You living in the USA can’t image what goes on in the Middle East.
"AsaJew..."
I suspect that if Israel removes the threat of its military retaliation very soon there will be no Israel.
And I'm bumping this because the Substack code is too stoopid to see I'm just endorsing it myself. :)
Sally Rooney may be hit and miss, but this is dreadful criticism.
Also you clearly don’t understand the situation of the Palestine Action group in the UK
Yeah, it’s a terrorist supporting organization. Not particularly complicated.
The UK judiciary are undecided about that, several judges now finding against the government, it's going to appeal. So this is not as slam-dunk settled as you seem to think. Criminal damage can be prosecuted but there is often a valid reasonable defence. Trivial example: in a fire one can break down a door to save a life. Can one spray paint weapons to stop them being used against civilians? I think so.
That will also prevent them being used against assailants.
Count the body bags, each side.
What's to be understood about a group which struck a woman in the back with a sledgehammer and goes about in the night daubing Jewish-owned businesses with red paint meant to look like blood?
One person atryck the police officer. I condemn that. But to condemn the group for the actions of one person would have every group condemned. One rogue IDF soldier would condemn Israel. But there are many thousands of war criminals in the IDF! Let's hear you speak out against that.
I like how you immediately jump to the conclusion that anyone who thinks there are good reasons to proscribe Palestine Action couldn't possibly think Israel has committed war crimes.
Not everything is a game of "arguments as soldiers".
And if you think Samuel Corner is the sole bad apple in Palestine Action and the rest of them are angels who wouldn't hurt a fly, you are sorely mistaken. Corner broke the police officer's spine in the middle of a terrorist action in which he and has compatriots caused £1.2 million in property damage.
And, obviously, you don't even consider daubing red paint on Jewish-owned businesses in the UK worthy of condemnation. I wonder why.
There are few angels. But a good cause is a good cause despite its proponents. I'm not going to condemn arithmeticians simply because Hitler also believed 2+2=4. Similarly Zionism is a bad idea even though Hitler was a supporter of it 🙂. Don't condemn the idea because you don't like some of those who express it because then no idea is good.
However, silence is too often too telling. Silence is too often nothing but cowardly complicity.
Calling a writer 'terrible' because their work doesn't conform to 19th-century standards of interiority or scope sets a rather impossible bar.
If we judge every artistic era by whether it mimics the grand, operatic architecture of Victorian realism, we miss how different registers function. Modern minimalism uses flat prose and suppressed subtext intentionally—not out of incompetence, but as a diagnostic tool for a different kind of human experience. Conflating personal distaste for a register with 'bad writing' just closes the door on actual criticism.
Flat prose is boring to read and if you can't get at the subtext as a reader then there is little point in the book. I read for plessure, not to have a world view shoved at me in a limited vocabulary.
I see what you mean, but I think the subtext in flat prose is actually found in what isn't being said.
When an author strips away all the decorative adjectives, speech marks, and internal monologues, they force you to read between the lines of the dialogue. The restraint is the point—the emotion isn't handed to you on a silver platter; it's buried in the cold, clinical distance between the characters.
It’s definitely a polarising style, but when it works, the 'boredom' is actually tension.
Not for everyone,though. Not your cuppa.
Do you like these American haikus from Kerouac?
In my medicine cabinet
the winter fly
has died of old age
------
Well here I am
2 pm.
What day is it?
------
The tree looks
like a dog
barking at heaven
------
No telegram today,
only more
leaves fell
-------
Prayerbeads
on the Holy Book
-My knees are cold
------
They are not haikus. Some are just words arrange as short poems. No, I don't like them.
We can call them short, three-line snapshot poems if you like. It's all the same to me.
Jack Kerouac’s American haikus are not traditional Japanese haikus because they abandon the rigid 5-7-5 syllable structure, yet they are intentionally crafted as an adapted Western form.
I love Japanese haikus, but I'm no purist. Do you like Japanese haikus?
Does this mean Fifty Shades of Grey is well-written?
No, it means Normal People is badly written. That does not mean that all Rooney's work is bad.
I wouldn't know. I've never read it. You?
I dipped into it out of curiosity. IMO to write that shite that badly should be a criminal offence (and I'm not joking)
The author cut and pasted huge chunks from different pages (eg say page 17 sex) into other sex scenes (say page 222).
I cannot think of a worse book ever.
But apart from that it's OK
Bits. It's like chewing tasteless chewing gum.
Isn't your sentence redundant? You could minimalist it by deleting 'chewing'. It's obvious what kind of gum you're referring to. 😎😉
Out of curiosity, are you familiar with Kerouac's Mexico City Blues?
I ask because it's the exact polar opposite of Rooney's flat minimalism. It's written like a chaotic jazz jam session with a massive, spontaneous vocabulary, but it poses the same problem from the other direction—the subtext is so buried in the linguistic noise that you have to fight just to find a coherent worldview.
If Rooney is too empty for you, I’m curious if you think Kerouac is too loud, or if that’s closer to what you mean by reading for pleasure.
I have not read NORMAL PEOPLE and don't feel drawn to it, but I found INTERMEZZO to be an interesting and stylistically varied portrait of a particular social milieu whose characters grew and gained insight into themselves. So the broadbrush generalizations of Rooney's writing that you extrapolate from this some years old book, even if, for the sake of argument, you are right about it, are unpersuasive. As for her deserving a taste of her own medicine, two wrongs don't make a right. I dislike cultural boycotts and governmental policies that restrict expressive activity even more.
I agree with your comments on Intermezzo. I was really drawn into the lives of the two brothers and found their relationship portrayed a considerable depth of emotion.
Again?
Move on Liza.
Yours is the best comment!!
Thank you for saving me the trouble of reading these two awful books. Not that I had the slightest intention of reading either of them, but the juxtaposition of the two BDSM passages is marvelously revealing.
What is going on? When I was growing up, the world was still pretty small for most people. We turned to books to broaden our experience. Thanks to the Web and the hundred-channel universe, the world is now much too big for most people. They feel lost in it. As a result, they seem to desperately crave affirmation of their particular place in it.
You can see this everywhere. Christian literature, for instance, whatever it pretends, is not evangelizing, either in purpose or effect. It is affirming its readers in their existing faith and in their righteousness. The Marxist-feminist literature similarly exists to affirm primarily young women in their prejudices and fears. They have been taught that trust and dependency are dangerous and will lead to a loss of self, which leaves not much but a howling wasteland of fear and desire in their relationships with men. They seek affirmation that this miserable existence they have claimed for themselves is normal and justified, and the Sally Rooneys of the world supply that affirmation.
But reading for affirmation is a very different thing from reading for experience. Experience is rich and detailed and particular and open-ended. It opens gates; it doesn't build fences. Reading for affirmation, on the other hand, sticks to familiar ground. Rich detail is superfluous. Particularity of experience is beside the point, because it is the assurance of absolute sameness and familiarity that is wanted. It exists only to say, yes, the world is just what you think it is, and it's not your fault, but someone else's.
And this is why I keep insisting that great literature is not about great ideas. That is just another form of affirmative literature. It differs only in what it is affirming. It appeals only to those who want that particular idea affirmed.
Sally Rooney, then, is writing just as she should for the kind of book she is writing, for the kind of audience she is writing it for. Literary style should fit the kind of book you are writing and the kind of audience you are writing it for. Sally Rooney is clearly good at what she does. The problem is that she affirms that which should not be affirmed at all.
The antidote to this is not to produce a work that affirms the opposite. It is to produce works that provide particular authentic human experience through specific stories of unforgettable characters. Experience is the acid that destroys bad ideas. That is the kind of book that stands a chance of curing a reader of their desire to be affirmed in Sally Rooney world.
I don’t think Rooney’s writing’s bad.
Yes, but that doesn't even matter. She's being attacked for her political views. In the UK free speech is under attack.
Oh wow, gotta strongly disagree with you here. I love her sentences. 10/10
There She goes with Sally Rooney again….🙄
Keep fighting the good fight, Liza!
I know nothing about this writer. But that her political interests come up right away in judgments of the aesthetic merit of her writing is the butcher's thumb on the scale.
Sally Rooney gets top Marx for novel writing.